I Was Challenged to Do My Makeup with Only Crayon and Pencil Products

Not easy for someone who loves using brushes the way I do!
Avatar:
Tamara
Author:
Publish date:
Social count:
56
Not easy for someone who loves using brushes the way I do!

My obsession with makeup brushes has been well-documented on xoVain, but recently, a friend challenged me to do a full face of makeup with crayon-style products. I shrugged my shoulders and thought, Why not? 

Let’s give it a whirl, shall we?

The Rules

  • All products must be in a crayon, pencil, or stick format
  • I can have ONE non-stick item to complete the whole look (and I only got this little “cheat” through much groveling)
  • NO brushes!
  • NO CRYING! (OK, I made that up because I’m dramatic.)

I ran into my first hiccup immediately as I always start my makeup with Urban Decay Eye Primer Potion, and I have no stick format primers. Womp womp. I ended up just diving in with a long-wearing cream shadow stick and hoping for the best.

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Cream Shadow Stick in Dusty Mauve. This formula is not as good as the pot version, in my opinion.

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Cream Shadow Stick in Dusty Mauve. This formula is not as good as the pot version, in my opinion.

What I like about shadow formulas like this is that you don’t necessarily need a brush to blend it in. I ran it across my lids a couple of times and then blended it upwards to just above my crease using my pinky finger.

I typically go with pencil for my brows but I use a spoolie to brush them out too, so I switched it up and tried a crayon brow product.

This gives a more solid brow look than I would typically use, but I was able to blend any harsh spots with my pinky (which, after this challenge, I will now and forever call “old faithful”).

I decided to make things easy on myself and used that same crayon to line my upper lash line and to add a bit of dimension to the crease of my eyelids.

For foundation, I used the Make Up For Ever Ultra HD Invisible Cover Stick Foundation, which I've talked about before, because I could double it up as a concealer as well since it’s so full-coverage.

For lips, I used a bright pink lip liner to line and fill in my lips and then topped it with a glossy nude lip crayon.

This pencil is from NYX and is in the shade Fuchsia. The crayon I layered over it is the Sexy Mother Pucker Gloss Crayon from Soap & Glory, but I wore the shade off the label.

This pencil is from NYX and is in the shade Fuchsia. The crayon I layered over it is the Sexy Mother Pucker Gloss Crayon from Soap & Glory, but I wore the shade off the label.

I finished the look off by applying some Tyra Cheek in a Stick to my cheeks for a nice soft flush.

crayon makeup 4.jpg

This challenge actually ended up being a little harder than I thought it would be. The final look is pretty subtle, and I was hoping to be able to do something unbelievably glam just using crayon-style products.

In retrospect I would have deepened the liner and the mascara but otherwise I like the simplicity of the eye.

In retrospect I would have deepened the liner and the mascara but otherwise I like the simplicity of the eye.

If I could have begged ONE MORE PRODUCT out of my friend it would have been setting powder.

If I could have begged ONE MORE PRODUCT out of my friend it would have been setting powder.

  • Would this be a challenge for you, or do you already use your fingers for everything? 
  • What are your favorite crayon products?